This comparison contains affiliate links. The Sign Codex may earn a commission if you sign up through them, at no extra cost to you. It does not change our assessment.
Keen and Psychic Source represent two different philosophies. Keen is a huge open marketplace; Psychic Source is a carefully screened, curated service. Both are well established, but they suit different priorities. This honest comparison lays out the trade-offs. As always, we treat a reading as a tool for reflection, not a guaranteed forecast.
Keen vs Psychic Source at a glance
| Keen | Psychic Source | |
|---|---|---|
| New-customer offer | 3 free min + 5 min for $1 | Few free min + intro as low as $1/min |
| Rates | ~$1.99 to $15+/min | ~$4.99 to $18.99/min |
| Screening | Light (identity only) | Rigorous (interview + background check) |
| Formats | Phone, chat, email | Phone, chat, video |
| Best for | Choice and low entry price | Vetted, consistent readers |
Screening and consistency
This is the core difference. Keen verifies identity but does not test reading ability, so its large roster varies a lot in quality. Psychic Source runs a video interview and background check and enforces a code of ethics, removing advisors who draw repeated complaints. If consistency matters most, Psychic Source has the edge; if you enjoy vetting readers yourself, Keen gives you more to choose from.
Pricing
Keen has the lower entry point, with newer readers around $1.99 per minute and a 5-for-$1 trial. Psychic Source’s standard rates start higher, around $4.99 per minute, though its intro offer drops the first reading to about $1 per minute. For the cheapest ongoing rates, Keen usually wins; for a screened reader at a low intro price, Psychic Source is competitive.
Formats
Both offer phone and chat, but only Psychic Source adds video, plus advisor video profiles that make choosing easier. If you want to see your reader or watch a profile first, Psychic Source is the clear pick.
Refunds and support
Keen offers up to $25 in credits once a month. Psychic Source has price-protection features and removes advisors who generate complaints, though some users report billing and technical issues. Both resolve problems with credits rather than cash.
Which should you choose?
Choose Keen if you want the widest selection, the lowest ongoing rates, and you are happy to vet readers using the intro minutes. Choose Psychic Source if you value heavy screening, want video as an option, and prefer consistency over the rock-bottom price.
Keen vs Psychic Source: frequently asked questions
Which is more accurate?
Accuracy varies by individual reader on both. Psychic Source’s heavier screening makes the experience more consistent, but no platform can guarantee accuracy, so treat any reading as reflection.
Which is cheaper?
Keen generally has lower ongoing rates. Psychic Source starts higher but offers a low first-reading intro of around $1 per minute.
Which has video readings?
Psychic Source. Keen offers phone, chat, and email but not video.
Want the details on each? Read our Keen review and Psychic Source review, or see all options in our guide to the best online psychic reading sites. Prefer to start free? Pull a free tarot card.